What Can We Say about Religion after the Blue Tsunami?

Election after election, narratives about how religion plays a role in politics have been the same: an overwhelming majority—more than 80%—of white evangelicals vote Republican, representing a formidable voting bloc. It began with electing Donald Trump to the presidency in 2016 and continued with incredible consistency through the midterms on November 3, 2026.
The results this time, however, were dramatically different and blue. So surely what we have in the making is a different story about religion.
Notable observations include:
Mark Silk’s Religion News Service commentary that “golden rule” Christianity, for once, prevailed, a stance not dissimilar to that of journalist Ruth Graham in the New York Times, who drew a distinction between the staunch, potent conservatism in big Texas and the new progressive approach.
An Axios article briefly notes that while 82% of white evangelicals voted red, their share of the vote markedly declined from 23% in 2024 to 17% in 2026, suggesting some simply stayed away, even though they usually show up in an outsized way. It quotes PRRI’s Robert P. Jones, reminding us that white evangelical numbers are slowly declining over the long term, so it might also be more than a matter of not showing up.
The Axios article also points to the increase of the religiously unaffiliated or “nones” voting in the midterms at 27% of voters, up from previous election cycles.
So while theological progressives seem to have had a better-than-banner day, finally, white evangelicals are still mostly conservative in how they vote. There were just fewer of them at the midterm polls, perhaps due to lower turnout and declining numbers. But, as far as religious affiliation goes, the nones meaningfully helped create the momentum.
That is a different story indeed. Could it be that the stranglehold of evangelical politics is finally subsiding? I think we’ll first need to see another election or two, when the economy isn’t so unequivocally bad for the average person. But at least for this election, we do have something new to say about religious affiliation and politics. Whew.
But Wait, There’s More
All that said, I would suggest there’s a more evocative story emerging. The observations above are mostly the demographic trends and ideological talking points we often default to when talking about religion and elections. What if, instead, we look less at demographics and ideologies and more at the practical shape and function of religion in the United States? If we make this election into a story about progressive versus conservative religion, it presumes that religion is a stable feature. But it could also be more about a decentering of conventional religion as an arbiter of cultural identity and morality. It could also be more about an enchantment of what animates our political life—that is, bringing spirituality into public life, not necessarily religion as we’ve known it.
The evidence, I would suggest, is right before our eyes in the form of pastors turning into politicians.
First, a caveat. From one perspective, there’s nothing new about this story. Pastors have turned politicians, for better or for worse, arguably since the beginning of time. Significantly, perhaps the most notable recent example is Georgia’s Senator Raphael Warnock, who was senior pastor of Atlanta’s Ebenezer Baptist Church. In fact, it should be obvious that the Black church and Black pastors have been politically active for decades, with the most extraordinary example being Martin Luther King, Jr., who arguably was indeed a politician.
But what is new is perhaps a greater number, or perhaps more importantly, the meaningful impact and greater force with which these recent pastors are stepping out of the institutional church, or at least what we might say is the conventional institutional church. Even if just anecdotally, look at the fact that six races were won by democratic clergy identified in Jack Jenkins’s RNS article, whereas only two winning clergy were Republican. Additionally, most of the red pastors were running in red areas, but the blue pastors often flipped red ones at the state or local level, so they're worth noting.
The key point is that these six winning pastors became liberal, not conservative, politicians, trading the pulpit for the legislative chamber:
Rev. Freddie Haynes III is a Progressive National Baptist megachurch pastor from Dallas. Haynes holds a Doctor of Ministry from the academically serious Graduate Theological Union. His Haynes for Congress bio says that his Friendship West Church is “a hub for civic engagement, economic empowerment, voter education, workforce development, and social change.” That’s religion as a social justice statement, which contrasts sharply with his Dallas megachurch neighbor, Robert Jeffress’s focus on ideological correctness.
Emanuel Cleaver is a United Methodist minister not new to politics, so he’s an exception to the others in this list, but worth mentioning. In his tenth term as a Democratic congressperson from Kansas City, Missouri, and as a former first Black mayor of Kansas City, it’s enough to say that Cleaver is a Black pastor who now, for decades, has been putting his faith to work, unlike most of the progressive white individuals mentioned here.
Sarah Trone Garriott won Iowa’s district three for the House. Garriott has served as a state senator, Lutheran minister, and hospital chaplain. Her campaign website says, “Her journey from service worker to minister, nonprofit leader, and state legislator is a testament to her unwavering commitment to public service. . . .” Her nonprofit work involved food banks and interfaith advocacy. In this additional piece in Religion News Service, Tron Garriott twice uses the phrase “public servant” to describe different people like her going into politics. On the surface, that phrase might seem perfectly natural to apply to a pastor, but many pastors in the US instead spend more of their time building up cultural institutions (if not their own personal kingdoms) than spending their training to become politicians, even if perhaps they should.
Rev. Lindsay James won Iowa’s 2nd Congressional District. She is a Presbyterian minister and chaplain, and she got her start in politics at the state level. Her campaign website states that she is seeking political office because “our nation has turned away from its moral responsibility to ensure economic justice for all.” There’s little self-indulgent Hillsong spirituality in that statement, nor any hint of conservative religion.
Adam Hamilton is the first Democratic senator from Kansas in nearly a century, and he’s also a successful megachurch pastor and book author, which makes you wonder: Why is he leaving that work? Most pastors don’t give up megachurch leadership. This additional Religion News Service interview doesn’t reveal much about his internal motivations except that he felt that what he saw in recent Trumpian policymaking was simply wrong and bad for people. That might seem a simple motivation, but for a popular pastor to then conclude he should run for a major office is, for most like him, quite the leap.
James Talarico was a middle school educator first, then a politician, then a seminarian. I find him the most fascinating recent development. Someone taking the required, often quite practical courses for a Master of Divinity typically sees their immediate future as leading a church (all the other candidates had years of clergy experience), but Talarico may see seminary training, at least in part, as actually leading to political office. He successfully won a bid to be a US Senator, no less from Texas. Talarico has put himself on a very different path. What I see is someone who often values the spirituality of his religion (its emphasis on seeking what is sacred, true, morally accountable, and even beautiful) over its formal social expression (institutional church). Is this an aberration or an emerging feature of the role of religion in the US? Everything is spiritual, as some have said in recent years, but we just didn’t realize that meant politics too.
What Do We Make of This Recent Batch of Pastors Becoming Politicians?
Have some of these pastors simply used their church platforms to get elected? It’s part of the equation, no doubt. Are they simply seeking more and bigger power? That may be, but there’s a difference between the intentions of this new crew and the likes of televangelist Pat Robertson or radio evangelist Mike Huckabee in the past.
I’ve heard comments on social media that the midterm elections were a victory for “the church,” and specifically the progressive church. What we see above, however, seems less like a victory for the church as we know it—progressives winning and conservatives losing—and more like a victory for a church that may be becoming. These pastors turning into politicians is, functionally, an anti-church-as-we-know-it movement, whether conservative or progressive.
The United States has long been an unusually religious country, not because we are closer to God or exceptional people on the global stage, but because we’ve needed religion, as sociologist Will Herberg classically argued, to play a functional role. This is perhaps a somewhat social-psychological reading of Herberg: Religion helps us create community and identity in a wildly different society than that of our ancestors one hundred, five hundred, or even two thousand years ago. Religion has also been a part of US DNA from the very beginning: The Puritans weren’t just sexual prudes; they were a small band of political dissidents, attaching religion to politics long before today’s Christian nationalists came on the scene.
Other than perhaps the Black church, I don’t think that we can name a movement that has achieved large-scale status of reimagining pastors as public servants. In a way, that might never happen, because we do know that there is a massive movement of folks simply disengaging with religious life as we’ve conventionally known it. And by the looks of the religious demographics in the recent election, we have many religious nones to thank for the Democrats’ victories, not progressive church leaders and laypersons.
So this is no victory for the church, or for a better theological version of religion, like a pendulum swinging to and fro. Instead, I would venture that we have a new, significant, and very appropriate decentering of Christianity and a less socially and more functionally applied spirituality, whether Christian (Protestant or Catholic), Jewish and Muslim, other religion, or no affiliation. That is a very different kind of story.
I think we can see this decentering in the senator-elect from my state of Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed. He’s not a pastor, but someone many pastors might learn from. In interviews where religion is mentioned, you can hear him drawing on what seems like a simple, uncomplicated understanding of the differences between religion and politics. As a member of a minority religion, one often subject to ignorance, if not bigoted and hostile attitudes and behaviors, he perhaps better sees that it’s the moral principles of his religion that drive his approach to policy, but not necessarily the formal expressions of his religion. In other words, there is a spirituality to simply being human (we don’t need the 10 Commandments posted in Texas schools to tell us that murder is wrong). In other words, the content of our religious life helps us articulate that morality, but religion is not the morality itself. As a Muslim, El-Sayed doesn’t have the problem most Christians have, when we define, often exclusively, the religion itself as the morality, and not the moral principles as the morality.
Rather than a triumph for a theological view, or church as we know it, would it be that we instead better acknowledge our innate ability to bring a moral vision, and its accompanying feelings of confidence, beauty, enchantment, charisma, and hope, more to our public life?



_edited.jpg)
Comments